Everything about me is sensitive and everything that shouldn't create an imbalance does. The only moisturizer that works wonders for me is a homemade mixture of oils applied to a freshly washed face.
Mix equal parts Virgin, unrefined coconut oil and virgin olive oil (I do 1 ounce of each) in a color applicator bottle with a NARROW tip because you want EXTREMELY small drops. The moisture lasts all day, prevents wrinkles and imparts a glow, not a shine. If you are shiny, you're putting too much on (I use about 5 drops). An added bonus, is that the finished oil is antibacterial/antiseptic so it works to prevent breakouts.
Coconut oil is solid below 75 degrees so you may have to put the entire jar in a pot of hot water to melt some of the oil. Once mixed with the VOO, it should remain liquid. DO NOT MICROWAVE, this will destroy the antiseptic/antibacterial properties of the oil.