Does a terminally ill child in intolerable pain have a right to die?video
Protesters turned out again in Belgium ahead of Thursday's parliamentary
vote to abolish age restrictions applying to its laws on euthanasia.
proposed legislation which will extend the right to ask to die to under
18 year-olds has aroused strong opinions across the country.
some fear vulnerable children may be talked into an irreversible choice
others see its as a merciful release for terminally ill youngsters.
Belgium's Parliament will vote on that difficult question Thursday.
The euthanasia bill is widely supported -- but has stoked fierce opposition from critics.
legalized euthanasia in 2002 for those in "constant and unbearable
physical or mental suffering that cannot be alleviated." Minors were
included in the original proposals but were left out of the final
legislation for political reasons.
The new bill would extend the
"right to die" to those under the age of 18 only under certain strict
conditions, including that the child is judged able to understand what
euthanasia means. Consent of parents or guardians must also be given.
If approved by the Parliament in Brussels, the bill will go to the king to be signed into law.
Mother Linda van Roy, from Schilde, Belgium, is among those backing the bill.
She could do nothing to help her terminally ill baby, Ella-Louise, in the last hours of her life.
Ella-Louise, who was only 10 months old when she died just over two years ago, would never have qualified for euthanasia.
her mother had to watch as her baby -- who had Krabbe disease, a rare
and terminal genetic mutation which damages the nervous system -- slowly
faded away under palliative sedation, food and liquid withheld so her
suffering was not further prolonged.
Children should 'have a choice'
whole period of sedation, you always need to give more and more
medication, and you start asking questions. And you say, 'What's the use
of keeping this baby alive?'" van Roy said.
She wishes she could
have administered a fatal dose of medication to make the end of her
daughter's short life come more quickly.
That's why she's
campaigning for a change to Belgium's euthanasia laws, to give the
choice of ending their suffering to older children whose bodies are
wracked with pain.
"We want for those children to be able to talk
about euthanasia and to ask those questions and if they really want to
say, 'Stop, this is it, I don't want it any more,' that they can have a
choice," van Roy said.
Pediatrician Gerlant van Berlaer, from the
Free University Brussels, is among the medical professionals backing
the change in the law.
"Doctors do terminate lives, of
children as well as adults," he said. "But today it is done in, let's
say, a 'grey zone,' or in the dark, because it is illegal," he said.
But others question whether children have the capacity to take this most final of decisions for themselves.
nurse Sonja Develter, who specializes in end-of-life care for children,
told CNN she is concerned that giving children a choice would mean they
made decisions based on what they thought their families wanted to
hear, and that this would be a terrible strain for children who may
already feel they are a burden to their caregivers.
'If you leave, you leave forever'
Izabela Sacewicz has Huntington's Disease, a neurological disease which drastically reduces life expectancy in children.
years ago she was a bubbling, active child -- top of her class,
according to her mother Iwona. Having recently turned 18, she can't eat
or walk without help. She finds it difficult to speak, but her mind is
still her own.
In a painful exchange, her mother explains to her what euthanasia is, using the simplest terms she can think of.
means if you are unwell, you are so unhappy that you don't want to stay
here, you want to leave, to go high up to God," she says. "But if you
leave, you leave forever."
Izabela listens, the strain showing on her face.
"Do you think it's good, or not good?" her mother asks.
"It's not good," she replies, the words barely audible.
says that with enough support, no parent would think of euthanasia --
and that Belgium's lawmakers should instead focus on providing better
support for families caring for terminally ill children.
insist the new law is more a matter of principle than anything else --
and that only a very small number of children will ever, in practice,
ask to end their lives through euthanasia.
Under its strict
guidelines, no doctor would be forced to carry out euthanasia against
his or her will and the child would always have the option of palliative
A child psychologist or psychiatrist would have to
examine the child to make sure that he or she is capable of making the
In the Netherlands, where children have been able to
request euthanasia with parental consent since 2002, only five children
have ever done so.
Edited by tatee - Feb 13 2014 at 12:30pm